I dont have a modem. I have a router & use it occasionally.

Mostly I use direct connection i.e
I have a PPPOE connection i.e internet wire RJ45 goes directly into the laptop.

And I also use Mobile connection i.e as Hotspot.

No probs with any FW “Public” profile with the above mentioned connection And with router too.

Why Avast IS “Public” profile blocks connections?